Open problems
126 problems that still stand between us and life on other worlds, each with the best answer so far.
Readiness scores and best answers are XLight’s own estimates, not official ratings.
- Open
How do you turn a heat shield around between flights?
Best answer so farInspect it in orbit, as Flight 15 did, so a tile-by-tile repair list exists before landing. If tiles never turn around fast enough, the other route is an actively cooled metal shield.
- Open
How do you move hundreds of tonnes of propellant between two ships in orbit?
Best answer so farNobody has done it yet. The first test is expected early in 2027. Larger tankers reduce how many transfers a mission needs.
- Open
How does a booster come back with propellant to spare?
Best answer so farShut the engines down about a second earlier on ascent and make engine performance more consistent. It costs a little payload.
- Open
How many tanker flights can one Moon departure tolerate?
Best answer so farEvery flight has to work, so fewer is better. A planned larger ship is estimated to cut a lunar refill to five or six launches.
- Open
How do you protect a crew from radiation for months?
Best answer so farPut water, food and plastic around the sleeping area as a shelter for solar outbursts, and shorten the trip. Nothing light enough yet stops the steady background of cosmic rays.
- Open
How do you land twenty tonnes on Mars?
Best answer so farThe heaviest thing landed so far is about one tonne. Parachutes stop scaling, so the plan is a large heat shield followed by engines fired into the supersonic airflow, which returning boosters already do on Earth.
- Open
How do you keep super-cold propellant from boiling away for months?
Best answer so farShade the tanks behind layered sunshields, wrap them in insulation, and run coolers that carry away the heat that leaks in. Storage at this scale has not been flown.
- Open
How do you stop Moon dust destroying seals and joints?
Best answer so farThe dust is sharp and clings by static charge. Answers being tested include electric dust shields that shake it off surfaces, tighter seals, and keeping suits outside the cabin.
- Open
How do you keep a base alive through a two-week lunar night?
Best answer so farSolar panels are dark for about fourteen days. The options are a small fission reactor, stored energy, or sites near the poles where sunlight is almost continuous.
- Open
How do you grow enough food without resupply?
Best answer so farWater recycling is nearly closed, but food is not. Crops have been grown in orbit only as small experiments; a full diet needs far more area, light and reliability.
- Open
How do you keep bones and muscles strong without weight?
Best answer so farStation crews exercise about two hours a day and still lose some bone. The untested alternative is to spin the ship so the crew feels weight.
- Open
How do you keep orbits usable as they fill up?
Best answer so farSatellites increasingly dodge each other automatically, and US rules now require new ones to leave orbit within five years of retiring. Removing large dead objects is still at the demonstration stage.
- Open
How do you run a mission when a message takes up to 22 minutes to arrive?
Best answer so farA signal between Earth and Mars takes 3 to 22 minutes each way, and the Sun blocks it for about two weeks every 26 months. The crew and their software must make the urgent decisions; Earth can only advise.
- Open
How do you live through a Mars dust storm?
Best answer so farStorms can dim the Sun for weeks, and one ended a solar-powered rover’s mission in 2018. The answers are nuclear power, oversized solar arrays with storage, and a low-power mode to wait it out.
- Open
What do you do about toxic salts in Mars soil?
Best answer so farThe soil holds about half a percent perchlorate, which harms the thyroid. Keep dust out of the cabin, wash soil with water before growing in it, or grow without soil.
- Open
How do you lift off from Mars to come home?
Best answer so farNo rocket has ever launched from Mars. Either bring a small ascent rocket already fuelled, or make methane and oxygen there, which so far has only been shown by a toaster-sized oxygen maker.
- Open
How do you treat a medical emergency months from a hospital?
Best answer so farTrain one of the crew as a doctor, carry ultrasound and a compact surgical kit, and rely on guidance software, because advice from Earth arrives too late for emergencies.
- Open
How do you keep a small crew well through years of isolation?
Best answer so farCareful selection, private space, real work and regular contact with family help. Six people stayed sealed in a mock ship for 520 days in 2010 and 2011 and finished, with sleep and mood problems along the way.
- Open
How do you stop a landing rocket sandblasting everything nearby?
Best answer so farWith no air to slow it, soil blown by the engine flies for kilometres. A lander pitted an older probe 160 metres away in 1969. Land far off, behind a wall of piled soil, or on a hardened pad.
- Open
Who owns what is mined in space?
Best answer so farA 1967 treaty bans nations from claiming territory. The United States and a few other countries have since passed laws letting companies own what they extract. There is no worldwide agreement.
- Open
How do you fix things when the nearest spare part is months away?
Best answer so farCarry printers and raw material and make the part. The space station has printed plastic parts since 2014 and metal since 2024. Designing machines to share common parts helps as much.
- Open
How do you get rid of the heat from a data centre in orbit?
Best answer so farIn vacuum, heat leaves only as radiation, so each megawatt needs on the order of a thousand square metres of radiator. Large deployable panels and chips that run hotter are the options.
- Open
How do you make spacesuit gloves that hands can work in?
Best answer so farA pressurised glove fights every grip and injures fingernails on long spacewalks. Better joints help. Suits that squeeze the skin directly, with no gas pressure in the glove, are still experimental.
- Open
Can people have healthy children away from Earth?
Best answer so farNobody knows. No mammal has gone through a whole pregnancy in space, and both radiation and low gravity are risks. Animal studies come first; spinning habitats may turn out to be necessary.
- Open
How do you keep thousands of satellites from spoiling the night sky?
Best answer so farBright satellites streak telescope images. Darker coatings, sunshades and sharing exact orbits with observatories reduce it. What burning satellites leave in the upper air is still being studied.
- Open
How do you land within metres of where you aimed?
Best answer so farCameras that match the ground below to a stored map let a lander steer itself. A Japanese lander came down 55 metres from its target in 2024, though it ended on its nose.
- Open
How do you stop a launch pad destroying itself under a giant rocket?
Best answer so farThe first Starship launch dug a crater under its own pad. The fix was a thick steel plate that sprays water upward against the flame. It has survived the launches since.
- Open
How do you light dozens of engines at the same moment?
Best answer so farStart them in groups a fraction of a second apart, check each one, and design the rocket to fly with a few out. The largest booster lights 33.
- Open
How do you restart an engine after hours of coasting?
Best answer so farPropellant drifts away from the tank outlet and the pipes warm up. Small thrusters push the propellant back first, and the pipes are chilled again before ignition.
- Open
How do you inspect a rocket fast enough to fly it again the same day?
Best answer so farToday it takes days. The hope is built-in sensors and enough flight history to skip most checks, as airlines do.
- Open
How do you land a booster on a ship in heavy seas?
Best answer so farThe ship holds position with thrusters and the booster aims for a moving deck. In bad weather the choices are to wait, to fly back to land, or to throw the booster away.
- Open
How do you protect a booster’s engines as it falls back tail-first?
Best answer so farFire some engines to slow down before the air thickens, and shield the base. Engines still come back scorched and need checking.
- Open
How do you live next to a spaceport that launches every day?
Best answer so farThe largest rockets rattle windows many kilometres away, and returning stages make sonic booms. Limits on night launches and buying out the nearest homes are the current answers.
- Open
How do you launch often without closing the sky and sea for hours?
Best answer so farEach launch closes airspace and shipping lanes. Narrower zones that reopen the moment the rocket has passed are being introduced.
- Open
How do you make sure a failing rocket ends its flight safely?
Best answer so farAn onboard computer tracks the rocket and destroys it if it strays, with no person in the loop. It replaced ground radars and made frequent launches possible.
- Open
How do you find a hydrogen leak before it stops a launch?
Best answer so farHydrogen slips through gaps nothing else can. Leaks delayed NASA’s Moon rocket repeatedly. Better seals help. Switching to methane avoids most of the problem.
- Open
How do you supply propellant for daily flights of a giant rocket?
Best answer so farOne flight burns several thousand tonnes of methane and oxygen. That means air-separation plants and gas pipelines at the pad, not tanker trucks.
- Open
What does rocket exhaust do to the upper atmosphere?
Best answer so farSoot and alumina particles left in the stratosphere can warm it and thin the ozone. Today the effect is small. At ten times the launch rate, nobody is sure.
- Open
How do you stop spent rocket stages becoming debris?
Best answer so farKeep enough propellant to steer the stage into the ocean, or at least empty its tanks so it cannot explode. Many older stages did neither.
- Open
How do you weld giant tanks without hidden flaws?
Best answer so farA flaw found in a tank dome pushed one new rocket’s first flight into the following year. Ultrasound scans of every weld and pressure tests are the defence.
- Open
How do you bring down a 420-tonne space station?
Best answer so farA dedicated tug will push it into the atmosphere over the emptiest part of the Pacific, so that the pieces that survive fall harmlessly. NASA has ordered the tug.
- Open
How do you keep one rocket failure from grounding everyone?
Best answer so farWhen a widely used rocket is grounded, satellites, cargo and crews all wait. Buying launches from several providers is the only defence, and there are few to choose from.
- Open
How do you license launches as fast as rockets can fly?
Best answer so farRegulators review each new flight plan for public safety, which can take longer than building the rocket. Licences covering a whole family of flights are the reform under way.
- Open
Who rescues a crew stranded in orbit?
Best answer so farA treaty obliges countries to help astronauts in distress, but no rescue ship stands ready. In 2024 a crew waited nine months for a seat home after its capsule was judged unsafe.
- Open
How do you cool an engine nozzle hotter than the melting point of steel?
Best answer so farPump the cold propellant through channels in the nozzle wall before burning it, and run a film of unburnt fuel along the inside.
- Open
How do you keep people in orbit after the space station retires?
Best answer so farThe station is due to come down around 2030 and no replacement is flying. If private stations are late, China’s will be the only one.
- Open
How do you get floating propellant to settle before a transfer?
Best answer so farIn weightlessness liquid drifts in blobs. A gentle, steady push from thrusters moves it to one end of the tank, where pressure or pumps can move it on.
- Open
How do you measure how much propellant is left in a tank in orbit?
Best answer so farA floating liquid has no level to read. Methods being tested include radio waves that sense the tank’s contents, and careful bookkeeping of every burn.
- Open
How do you dock two hundred-tonne ships without damage?
Best answer so farApproach at centimetres a second and latch softly. Capsules and stations have done it for decades. Two ships this large never have.
- Open
What happens if a heat shield tile falls off?
Best answer so farIt cannot be replaced in flight. The answer is a backup layer under the tiles that survives one re-entry, and inspection in orbit before coming home.
- Open
How do you keep a ship’s flaps from burning through at the hinges?
Best answer so farHot gas finds every gap. Moving the flaps out of the worst of the flow and sealing the hinges has reduced the damage with each flight.
- Open
How do two satellites avoid each other when their owners never talk?
Best answer so farMost warnings still travel by e-mail. Automatic exchange of planned manoeuvres between operators is beginning, but there is no common system.
- Open
Who has the right of way in orbit?
Best answer so farNo rule says. In practice the satellite that can manoeuvre moves, and operators settle it case by case.
- Open
How do you track debris too small to see?
Best answer so farRadars follow objects down to a few centimetres. Smaller pieces, which can still destroy a satellite, are only counted statistically.
- Open
What do you do with a satellite that dies before it can leave orbit?
Best answer so farFly lower, so that thin air removes failures within a few years, or pay a tug to pull it down. Neither is yet required.
- Open
What does burning up thousands of satellites do to the upper air?
Best answer so farEach one leaves aluminium oxide in the stratosphere. Measurements show the metal is already there. Its effect on ozone is not yet known.
- Open
How do radio telescopes work with satellites transmitting overhead?
Best answer so farBy agreement, operators switch off beams when passing over observatories. That does not stop unintended radio leakage from the satellites’ electronics.
- Open
How do you share radio spectrum among dozens of constellations?
Best answer so farAn international body allocates frequencies, first come, first served. Sharing rules written for a few satellites are being renegotiated for tens of thousands.
- Open
How do you reach an ordinary phone from 500 km up?
Best answer so farThe signal is weak and the satellite moves at 7.5 km a second. A very large antenna, and correction for the shifting frequency, make it work.
- Open
How do you protect satellites from a solar storm?
Best answer so farA storm heats the upper air, which drags satellites down, and charges their electronics. Operators get hours of warning and can do little more than turn satellites edge-on and wait.
- Open
How do you stop a satellite network being hacked?
Best answer so farAn attack on ground modems cut satellite internet across Europe in 2022. Encryption, signed software updates and separated networks are the defences.
- Open
How do you use ordinary chips in space radiation?
Best answer so farRadiation-proof chips are years out of date. Cheap chips are flown in threes that vote, with circuits that reset a part when a particle upsets it.
- Open
How do you grab a satellite that was never meant to be grabbed?
Best answer so farHold it by the ring that once attached it to its rocket, or by its engine nozzle. Both have been done. A tumbling satellite has not been caught.
- Open
How do you refuel a satellite with no filling port?
Best answer so farA robot must cut insulation, unscrew caps and fit a hose. That was shown on a test panel outside the space station, never on a working satellite.
- Open
How do you keep a satellite in very low orbit from falling?
Best answer so farThin air there drags it down within weeks. Continuous electric thrust, a slender shape and, in future, engines that use the air itself are the answers.
- Open
How do you hold a laser on a satellite thousands of kilometres away?
Best answer so farAt that distance the beam is narrower than a football pitch. Fine steering mirrors track a beacon from the other satellite thousands of times a second.
- Open
How do you get laser signals through cloud?
Best answer so farYou cannot. Ground stations spread across different climates let the satellite pick one with clear sky.
- Open
How do you beam power to Earth without losing most of it?
Best answer so farEach conversion wastes energy: sunlight to electricity, to microwaves, and back. End-to-end efficiency in tests so far is well under ten percent.
- Open
How do you build something a kilometre wide in orbit?
Best answer so farLaunch it as thousands of identical tiles and let robots join them. Robotic assembly has been shown only for small trusses.
- Open
How do you get permission to land a capsule?
Best answer so farOne company’s first capsule waited months in orbit for a US re-entry licence in 2023 and 2024. Some companies now land in Australia.
- Open
What made in orbit is worth the trip?
Best answer so farSo far only products worth thousands of dollars a gram, such as some drug crystals and special glass fibres. Cheaper launches lengthen the list slowly.
- Open
How do you navigate when GPS is jammed?
Best answer so farSignals from low-orbit satellites are far stronger and harder to drown out. Clocks and star trackers carry a spacecraft through the gaps.
- Open
How do you tell an inspection from an attack?
Best answer so farA satellite approaching another could be servicing it or spying on it. Announcing manoeuvres in advance is the proposed norm. Few countries do it.
- Open
Who is liable when debris hits a satellite?
Best answer so farA 1972 treaty makes the launching country liable if fault is shown. Proving whose fragment it was is nearly impossible, and the treaty has been formally invoked once.
- Open
Who pays to remove old debris?
Best answer so farThe largest dead objects were left by governments decades ago. Nobody is obliged to remove them. A few agencies now fund single removal missions.
- Open
How do you insure a satellite in a crowded orbit?
Best answer so farInsurers paid out more than they earned in some recent years, and several left the market. Many low-orbit satellites now fly uninsured.
- Open
Why does eyesight change in space?
Best answer so farBody fluid shifts toward the head and presses on the back of the eye. Many astronauts come home needing different glasses. Devices that draw fluid back to the legs are being tested.
- Open
What do cosmic rays do to the brain?
Best answer so farAnimal studies suggest heavy particles may impair memory. No person has received the dose of a Mars trip, so the risk is uncertain.
- Open
How do you get warning of a solar outburst in deep space?
Best answer so farLight from a flare arrives in eight minutes and the worst particles within the hour. The crew needs its own detectors, since a warning from Earth may come too late.
- Open
How much radiation is an acceptable risk?
Best answer so farNASA caps an astronaut’s career dose at a level that adds a few percent to the risk of dying of cancer. A Mars round trip would exceed it.
- Open
Why does the immune system weaken in space?
Best answer so farStress, poor sleep and radiation let dormant viruses, such as the one that causes shingles, reawaken in many astronauts. Exercise, sleep and vaccination before flight help.
- Open
How do you prevent kidney stones?
Best answer so farBones shed calcium into the urine, and a stone could end a mission. Crews drink more, exercise, and can take a preventive drug.
- Open
How do you operate when blood floats?
Best answer so farBlood and fluids would drift through the cabin. A sealed transparent enclosure over the wound, with suction, is the working design.
- Open
How do you keep medicines effective for three years?
Best answer so farSome drugs lose strength faster in space, possibly because of radiation. Better packaging, cold storage and making simple drugs on board are the options.
- Open
How do you stop slime clogging the water system?
Best answer so farBacteria form films inside pipes and valves, and have blocked equipment on the space station. Biocides, coatings and regular flushing keep them in check.
- Open
How low must carbon dioxide be kept?
Best answer so farStation crews report headaches at levels about ten times Earth’s, which older scrubbers allowed. Newer systems hold it lower, at a cost in power.
- Open
How do you put out a fire in weightlessness?
Best answer so farFlames burn as slow, dim spheres, and smoke does not rise to a detector. Crews cut the ventilation to starve the fire and use water-mist extinguishers.
- Open
How do you find a slow air leak?
Best answer so farOne leak on the space station took years to trace. Crews close hatches one by one, listen with ultrasound microphones, and once watched floating tea leaves drift toward the crack.
- Open
What do you do with rubbish?
Best answer so farToday it is packed into departing cargo ships that burn up. A long voyage needs compactors that recover the water and press the rest into radiation-shielding tiles.
- Open
How do you wash clothes?
Best answer so farYou do not. Clothes are worn for days and thrown away, because washing takes water the ship cannot spare. Detergents that work in very little water are being tested.
- Open
How do you keep food worth eating for five years?
Best answer so farVitamins break down, and crews tire of the menu and eat less. Variety, fresh crops and better packaging are the answers so far.
- Open
How do you sleep without day and night?
Best answer so farCrews average about six hours and often use sleeping pills. Lighting that shifts colour through the day helps keep the body clock.
- Open
How do you settle a quarrel with no way out?
Best answer so farCrews are chosen and trained for it, and long simulations show tension peaking after the midpoint. With delayed radio, no outside mediator can step in.
- Open
How do you build a toilet that keeps working?
Best answer so farToilets have failed on the space station and on a private flight. Airflow replaces gravity, and every part must be repairable by the crew.
- Open
Is the gravity of the Moon or Mars enough for the body?
Best answer so farNobody knows. All long-term data comes from weightlessness or from Earth. Mice kept at lunar gravity in a centrifuge on the space station were only partly protected.
- Open
How fast can a habitat spin before people feel sick?
Best answer so farTurning the head in a spinning room upsets the inner ear. Ground tests suggest most people adapt to a few turns a minute, which means a radius of tens of metres.
- Open
How do you stand up on Mars after six months of weightlessness?
Best answer so farReturning astronauts need help walking for days. On Mars there is no ground crew, so the first tasks must be automated or must wait.
- Open
How harmful is breathing Moon dust?
Best answer so farApollo crews had sneezing and sore eyes. The grains are sharp and chemically reactive, and long exposure might scar the lungs. Keeping the dust out is the only protection.
- Open
How do you avoid the bends on frequent spacewalks?
Best answer so farSuits run at low pressure, so crews first breathe pure oxygen for hours. Cabins kept at lower pressure with more oxygen cut the wait to minutes.
- Open
How do you make one spacesuit design fit everyone?
Best answer so farOld suits came in few sizes, and a spacewalk was once reassigned for lack of a fit. New suits use swappable parts sized for small and large bodies.
- Open
How do you stay fit in a capsule with no room for a treadmill?
Best answer so farA flywheel device the size of a shoebox gives rowing and squat exercises. It flew with the crew round the Moon in 2026. Whether it is enough for months is untested.
- Open
How much ice is really at the Moon’s poles?
Best answer so farOrbiters detect hydrogen, and a probe crashed into a crater in 2009 threw up some water. Estimates differ a hundredfold. Only a drill on the ground will settle it.
- Open
How do you work at minus 230 degrees in permanent darkness?
Best answer so farMetals turn brittle, lubricants freeze and batteries stop. Machines need heaters, power sent by beam or cable from the sunlit rim, and short visits.
- Open
How do you stop a tall lander tipping over?
Best answer so farTwo tall landers ended on their sides in 2024 and 2025. Wider legs, a lower centre of mass and sensors that cancel sideways drift at touchdown are the fixes.
- Open
How do you find your position on the Moon?
Best answer so farThere is no GPS. Landers match camera views to maps. Faint GPS signals from Earth were picked up on the lunar surface in 2025, and lunar navigation satellites are planned.
- Open
What time is it on the Moon?
Best answer so farClocks there run about 56 millionths of a second a day faster than on Earth. Agencies are agreeing a lunar time standard so that navigation signals line up.
- Open
How do you survive temperature swings of 300 degrees?
Best answer so farNoon reaches about 120 degrees and night falls to about minus 170. Insulation, heaters, radiators with shutters, or burying equipment in soil even it out.
- Open
How dangerous are moonquakes?
Best answer so farApollo instruments recorded shallow quakes of up to about magnitude 5 that shook for ten minutes or more. Buildings there will need to flex.
- Open
How do you protect a base from meteorites?
Best answer so farWith no air to stop them, grains arrive at tens of kilometres a second. A metre or two of soil over the habitat stops nearly all of them.
- Open
How do you dig when the digger weighs a sixth as much?
Best answer so farA light machine cannot push hard into the ground. Twin drums that scoop in opposite directions cancel each other’s forces.
- Open
How do you get oxygen out of soil by the tonne?
Best answer so farLaboratory cells make grams. A plant would have to run at 1,600 degrees for years, fed by diggers, with a megawatt or more of power.
- Open
How do you protect historic sites on the Moon?
Best answer so farRocket exhaust and wheels could erase the first footprints. The United States asks visitors to keep their distance. No international rule exists.
- Open
How do you share the few best sites at the lunar south pole?
Best answer so farA handful of ridges get almost constant sunlight beside craters that may hold ice. Several countries want the same ones, and no process decides between them.
- Open
How do you keep Earth microbes off Mars?
Best answer so farRobots are cleaned and baked. People cannot be: a crew carries trillions of microbes. The likely compromise is to keep humans away from the places most promising for life.
- Open
How do you bring Mars samples home safely?
Best answer so farThe container must be sealed so that nothing that touched Mars is exposed on Earth, and opened only in a high-containment laboratory.
- Open
How much power does it take to make propellant on Mars?
Best answer so farFilling one large ship for the trip home needs roughly a megawatt running for about two years. That is several football pitches of solar panels, or a few small reactors.
- Open
How do you drive a thousand kilometres on Mars?
Best answer so farSharp rocks tore holes in one rover’s aluminium wheels within a few kilometres. Later rovers have thicker, differently shaped wheels and software that eases them over rocks.
- Open
How do you keep dust off solar panels and radiators?
Best answer so farDust ended one lander’s mission and nearly ended others. Wind sometimes cleans panels by luck. Tilting, brushing, blowing gas and electric fields are the deliberate options.
- Open
What if something breaks and the next ship is two years away?
Best answer so farEarth and Mars line up for a crossing only every 26 months. A crew must carry the spares and skills for everything, and the mission must survive without resupply.
- Open
How do you turn back on the way to Mars?
Best answer so farAfter the departure burn there is almost no way to. A few routes swing past Mars and return without stopping, but they take well over a year.
- Open
How do you slow a hundred-tonne ship arriving at Mars?
Best answer so farRockets alone would need a second ship’s worth of propellant. The plan is to shed most of the speed against the thin air with a large heat shield.
- Open
How do you shorten the six-month trip?
Best answer so farMore propellant, or better engines. Nuclear thermal rockets might cut it to about four months. Anything much faster needs engines that do not exist.
- Open
How do you test a nuclear rocket engine on Earth?
Best answer so farIts exhaust is radioactive, so open-air tests like those of the 1960s are no longer allowed. The exhaust must be captured and scrubbed, or the test done in space.
- Open
How do you launch a reactor safely?
Best answer so farLaunch it unused. Uranium that has never run in a reactor is barely radioactive, and the reactor is switched on only in a high, stable orbit or on the surface.
- Open
How do you cool a reactor where there is no air or water?
Best answer so farHeat can only be radiated away. Radiator panels make up much of the mass of any power plant in space.
- Open
How do you stop an asteroid found only months before impact?
Best answer so farYou probably cannot deflect it. Striking it with a spacecraft works with years of warning. With months, evacuating the impact area is the realistic plan.